Christmas Gift Guide for Colts Fans
Need a Christmas gift for a Colts fan? Start with our best picks they will actually use.
Trusted by 10,000+ five-star reviews, Playbook Products turns iconic Indianapolis Colts plays into gifts worth unwrapping.
Each pick below celebrates real plays from Indianapolis Colts history — including plays that still give you chills on replay. Find a Christmas gift he or she will actually unwrap and use below.
Perfect for the Home Bar
For the dad who loves game-day hosting, Colts slate coasters are an easy win: the perfect conversation piece that the still looks good in any room!
Each set features 4 different moments across different eras — from Hayden Pick Six to 4th Quarter Comeback.
High-quality slate elevates even the nicest room, and felt backing helps protect tables from scratches. Each set celebrates iconic plays from Indianapolis Colts history he'll recognize instantly.
For the Minimalist Dad
Colts leatherette coasters are perfect if you want something sleek, low-maintenance, and easy to wipe clean. They look great in an office, den, or living room. Perfect for everyday use, they will last for years with no sign of wear and tear.
Featuring iconic Indianapolis Colts plays — including Hayden Pick Six.
For the Coffee Drinker
For the dad who starts every morning with coffee, a Colts mug is the most dependable gift in the house. It turns his favorite Indianapolis Colts plays into part of the daily routine.
Whether it's 4th Quarter Comeback or Hayden Pick Six, browse the Colts collection to choose the plays he'll want to see every day.
For the T-Shirt Dad
If he's the kind of dad who lives in tees, this is the simplest win. A great sports t‑shirt feels personal without being complicated.
With designs like Ending the dynasty, rep Colts but have his friends say "woah, is that from our championship game?!"
For the New Dad (or the Granddad Who's Proud)
Shopping for a first Father's Day? A baby onesie is a sweet, low-pressure gift that still feels personal—especially when it matches the family's team — Colts.
Let Dad get the child ready for a lifetime of fandom — starting with Manning vs. Luck.
Common questions
Slate coaster sets and play-diagram coffee mugs are the best Christmas gifts for Colts fans — practical items they will use daily, each tied to real plays from Indianapolis Colts history.
Leatherette coasters, t-shirts, and baby onesies are strong picks too. This guide highlights our top Colts products with specific play examples you can match to their favorite era.
Each Colts slate coaster set includes four different plays from team history — including Hayden Pick Six, 4th Quarter Comeback, Ending the dynasty, and Manning vs. Luck.
Sets are engraved on natural slate with felt backing. Browse the Colts collection to see all available Colts coaster and mug designs.
Colts slate coasters or a play-diagram mug are ideal when he already owns apparel — they're useful at home or the office and feel personal because each design features a specific play, not just a logo.
Leatherette coasters are a polished bar upgrade; mugs work for daily coffee. Both show a real Indianapolis Colts play he'll recognize instantly.
Playbook Indianapolis Colts gifts use real play diagrams and plays from team history — not generic logo-only items.
Each product is tied to a moment fans remember (Hayden Pick Six, 4th Quarter Comeback, Ending the dynasty, and Manning vs. Luck), so the gift sparks conversation and nostalgia instead of blending in with another jersey in the closet.
Yes. Playbook Products offers Indianapolis Colts slate coasters, leatherette coasters, mugs, t-shirts, posters, and more — each featuring iconic team plays.
Shop the Colts collection or use the product picks on this Christmas guide for Colts fans.
Yes. Many Colts gifts let you pick a single play (mugs, tees, onesies), or choose a coaster set with four different plays across eras.
Open the Colts collection or the product page to browse every available Indianapolis Colts design.
Most orders ship within 1–3 business days and typically arrive 4–7 business days after you place your order (U.S.).
Exact timing can vary during peak Christmas volume — check the product page at checkout for current estimates.