Name: Greatest Buffalo Bills Plays: Slate Coasters (Set of 4)
Brand: Playbook Products
SKU: PB-CS-FT-PM-BUF_BILLS
Price: 49.99 USD
Availability: InStock

Greatest Buffalo Bills Plays: Slate Coasters (Set of 4)

Price

14,000+ Five-Star Reviews on Etsy
Perfect gift for any fan
Four unique plays in each set
As seen on ESPN, Barstool Sports, and more!

Relive Buffalo Bills history with this unique gift:
Bills Plays Coaster Set
4 distinct great moments

Capture four unforgettable moments from Bills history on natural slate coasters.

Buy for yourself or as a great gift idea for any dedicated Bills fan. These coasters are more than just functional and unique; they're a testament to your unwavering Bills love.

Product Features:

Set of four coasters laser-etched with the Buffalo Bills greatest moments.
Modern, classy, and unique. Perfect addition to any room's decor.
Precision and quality ensure every detail of the historic plays.
Crafted from 100% natural slate with natural edge for authenticity.
Felt backing to protect your tables.
Shipping Assurance: We guarantee safe delivery. If your coasters arrive cracked or damaged, we'll promptly send you replacements.

Bills plays included:

2024 Regular Season, Week 11 vs Kansas City
SuperAllen Run
2024 Regular Season, Week 13 vs San Francisco
Lake Effect Lateral
1994 AFC Championship Game vs Kansas City
Kings of the Conference
1993 AFC Wild Card Playoff vs Houston
The Comeback

⭐ 16,000+ Five Star Reviews across all storefronts ⭐

“One of the surprise Christmas gifts this year for hubby- he was THRILLED. When I showed our son when it came in the mail, he insisted it be from him, which is perfect, as football is one of the main things they have bonded over. Beautiful, high quality slate with a nice felt backing, and great graphics depicting the plays. For a lifelong Buffalo Bills Mafia member, this was perfect!”
- Lorena on December 29, 2025

“Got these Buffalo Bills slate coasters as a gift for my buddy who's a die-hard Bills fan, and he went nuts over them! The etchings nail those legendary moments – the insane Comeback against Houston in '93, Lindell's clutch field goal to beat the Pats in 2011, Thurman Thomas tearing it up with 186 yards and three TDs in the '94 AFC Championship, and that dominant first AFC title win over the Raiders in '91. The slate has this cool, rugged vibe with natural edges, and the play details are etched super clean and sharp. They're tough, keep the table safe from drinks, and they've already kicked off a ton of chats at his place. Killer unique gift for any Mafia member – total winner!”
- Marco on December 30, 2025

With each coaster, you'll not only protect your surfaces but also honor the unforgettable moments that define your Buffalo Bills fandom. Whether for yourself or as a gift for your father, friend, husband, or more - we know these coasters are sure to rock! (pun intended).

Order this unique coaster set today and let the memories live on.

2024 Regular Season, Week 11
SuperAllen Run
Bills vs Kansas City
30 - 21
17 November, 2024
This week 11 matchup brought the heat. The 9-0 Kansas City Chiefs, fresh off a victory of the Broncos, take on the 8-2 Buffalo Bills. However, the Bills would have the final say in this game. The Bills have a slim 2 point lead and only 2:27 seconds left in the 4th. They only needed two yards for a first down, but QB Josh Allen takes looks for the pass, then runs the ball. While most QB's may slide past the first down line, Josh Allen lowers the should twice and finds the endzone with only 2:17 left in the game. The Bills would go on to win this game 30-21 and end the unbeaten streak of the Kansas City Chiefs. This play will go down in history as one of the best of the 2024-25 season and best of Josh Allen's career.

2024 Regular Season, Week 13
Lake Effect Lateral
Bills vs San Francisco
35 - 10
1 December, 2024
Every snow game provides a unique play style and dramatic plays. This game was not different, with lots of run play or short passes. A quick throw from Josh Allen ends up behind the receiver Amari Cooper who manages to reign the ball in with one hand. 3 San Francisco players are right on top of him driving him back, however, Allen is wide open. A short lateral pass opens up the field and Josh Allen rushes to the front corner of the endzone, reaches out with his arm and scores the first touchdown of the 3rd quarter. A wild and wacky play leads to a big score and boosts the Buffalo Bills to a 28-3 lead over the San Francisco 49ers. The Bills would go on to win this game 35-10.

1994 AFC Championship Game
Kings of the Conference
Bills vs Kansas City
30 - 13
23 January, 1994
Buffalo won its 4th straight AFC Championship with stellar offense and crushing defense. The star of the game was Squirmin' Thurman Thomas who rushed for 186 yards and 3 TDs. His last TD on a 3-yard run off a handoff from QB Jim Kelly, put the game out of reach and secured Buffalo the title.

1993 AFC Wild Card Playoff
The Comeback
Bills vs Houston
41 - 38
3 January, 1993
Down 35-3 in the 3rd quarter the Bills began the greatest comeback in NFL playoff history, getting 4 TDs in the 3rd and 1 in the 4th. Frank Reich threw 3 of those TDs to Andre Reed, who had the grab in the 4th to give the Bills the lead. The Bills got the win in OT on a kick from Steve Christie.

Common questions

Are these a good gift for a Bills fan?

Yes. This coaster set is made for a Bills fan who really knows and loves the team. They’ll recognize moments like Lindell's game-winner and The Comeback, and each coaster gives them another piece of Bills history to talk about. It’s more than a logo on a coaster — it’s a way to relive the plays and memories that made them a fan. It’s especially suited to a dad, husband, friend, or hard-to-shop-for Bills fan who already owns the usual team gear.

Is this a good Christmas gift for a Bills fan?

Yes. These coasters make a unique Christmas gift for Bills fans, especially someone who already has plenty of jerseys, hats, and traditional team gear. Each coaster brings back a memorable moment from Bills history, making the set both useful and personal to someone who really follows the team. Our coaster sets are especially popular as Christmas gifts, with more than 16,000 five-star reviews across Shopify and Etsy.

One customer wrote: “The quality is insane, perfectly matched description. Bought for my dad for Christmas and as a man that is incredibly hard to buy for he loved them and are a great convo starter with his friends, Great gift would buy from this seller again.” — Etsy Customer, January 11, 2023

What makes these different from traditional sports merchandise?

These coasters focus on memorable plays rather than a team logo. Each one features an original Playbook diagram of a real Bills play, drawn to show how the moment unfolded. Playbook Products is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Bills or the NFL.

How long do Bills coaster orders take to ship?

Most Bills coaster orders are processed within 1–2 business days, then typically arrive 2–4 business days after they ship (U.S.). During busy holiday periods, processing can take longer. A delivery date shown on this page is an estimate.

What if a coaster arrives cracked or damaged?

Send us a photo of the damaged coaster within 14 days of delivery and we'll send a replacement. Please hold onto the damaged coaster until we let you know otherwise.

Are these coaster designs AI-generated?

No. I've spent hundreds of hours reviewing footage of these plays and drawing them up as they happened. The finished drawings are laser-etched onto the coasters using our own machines. The artwork is not generated by AI. I appreciate you supporting a small business.

What do customers say about Playbook coaster sets?

Playbook Products has more than 16,000 five-star reviews across our storefronts. Customers have described the coaster sets as unique gifts for sports fans who can be difficult to shop for. Recent customers have said:
“What an awesome gift. Especially if it’s for a person who has everything!! … It is now my new favorite gift!!” — Gerilyn, Sept. 30, 2026
“I gave this as a gift to a friend and he said it’s one of the best gifts he’s ever received! Enough said!” — La, Sept. 5, 2026

NOTICE: No sports player, team, league, or playoff is affiliated with Playbook Products or is the source of, is responsible for, or has endorsed, sponsored, or authorized these products or this website.

5 stars: 10199 (92%)
4 stars: 520 (5%)
3 stars: 180 (2%)
2 stars: 77 (1%)
1 star: 135 (1%)

Some of the reviews shown are from related products the merchant grouped with this one.

Love it. Great gift great quality

Etching is very light and hard to read. Not really deep into slate. I feel that this would wear off quickly.

Excellent, he really loved them!

Navy Football Greatest Plays: Slate Coasters

I wrote an earlier review as the only way I could communicate with Playbook but after they reached out to me, I am now completely satisfied with their Customer Service. So Big Thanks — Both your responsiveness and concern for quality product / customer satisfaction are very much appreciated.
I will be purchasing more as gifts in the future.

I ordered from you all a few years ago for a Chiefs fan and I thought this would be a great gift for my sports fanatic adoptive grandfather.

My son was so surprised at graduation with these coasters. Huge hit! Thank you so much!

Not very good quality. Only one coaster is fine, the other ones are missing pieces with the words. There’s a lot of space on top and not on the bottom where the words are.

We were shipped the wrong coasters and informed the seller immediately. They said they would ship out the correct set of coasters the next day. We told the seller we would need the coasters within the next week as they were for a birthday gift. It has now been 6 days and we still have not received any shipping information for the replacement coasters.

They are nice but not worth 43.00. They are thin.

Customer service responded quickly to my questions. Love the quality! Such a great gift for the Knicks fans!!

The coasters are high-quality leather, and the stitching around the edges is beautiful. My uncle was very pleased with how nice they turned out! The seller was very helpful and responsive when I had a question about my order. I highly recommend this item and store :)

My dad LOVED these and couldn’t believe his favorite play was in there!

My husband loves the new coasters. I’m a little disappointed with them as the print on them is faint and difficult to see.

Old display set?

I bought the fake leather coasters to give as a gift. The box for the coasters is damaged- the corners for the opening tab are torn/separated- possibly from people opening and
Closing the box. The box looks old and faded. I would not have bought this if I knew it would arrive like a used display, a second hand or returned set of coasters. Disappointed.☹️

Great Quality

Great quality and my boyfriend loved them! Make a great gift for any occasion.

Looks fantastic! The plays are really cool and clear. The stone is a bit fragile - there were a couple small crumbles off the edges - but I think that's expected with the material.

I was excited to get these for my Dodger loving husband for a gift and the item received is not...great. While the listing photos show very clear writing on the coasters, the coasters I received are not, blurry writing and hard to make out. The photo of the same one in the listing vs my photo to compare and it's not even close to the quality shown. Sad because I cannot give these as a gift and be happy about it because they are basically not readable. Have contacted the seller.

They came so quickly and look so clean for such fine details, I can’t wait to give them as a gift!!

These are absolutely beautiful but I will say that the white design is not nearly as bold and vibrant as it is in the photos which is kind of a disappointment. They are very well crafted however and felt completely covering the bottom to scratch tables/counters. Shipping was super fast. Again, I just wish they were more vibrant and not so dull looking but I would still recommend to any MI fan!

Got the Arsenal set to gift for a huge Arsenal fan, and it’s a really neat idea and it’s executed well! Nice materials, and I really like how the bottom of the coasters are kind of like a felt base, so they won’t scuff your tables. Seller was helpful when we were accidentally shipped the wrong thing, and was quick to mail out the correct set and get us the shipping label to return the wrong ones. Only “issue” I have is that some of the coaster designs are hard to read due to how the slate was cut. One corner is a little slanted/appears chipped (even though I know it’s just the unique cut) and one part has writing right in a little crevasse. Overall I’m excited to gift them, and I know that they’ll be well loved!