Relive Indianapolis Colts history with this unique gift:
Colts Plays Coaster Set
4 distinct great moments
Capture four unforgettable moments from Colts history on leatherette coasters.
Buy for yourself or as a great gift idea for any dedicated Colts fan. These coasters are more than just functional and unique; they're a testament to your unwavering Colts love.
Product Features:
-
Set of four coasters laser-etched with the Indianapolis Colts greatest moments.
-
Modern, classy, and unique. Perfect addition to any room's decor.
-
Precision and quality ensure every detail of the historic plays.
-
Highly durable leatherette provides longevity with no fading.
-
Shipping Assurance: We guarantee safe delivery. If your coasters arrive cracked or damaged, we'll promptly send you replacements.
Colts plays included:
2007 Super Bowl XLI vs Chicago
Hayden Pick Six
2003 Regular Season, Week 5 vs Tampa Bay
4th Quarter Comeback
2007 AFC Championship vs New England
Ending the dynasty
2013 Regular Season, Week 7 vs Denver
Manning vs. Luck
⭐ 16,000+ Five Star Reviews across all storefronts ⭐
“I got this gift for my boyfriend who is a Colts fan and he LOVED them. This is a one of a kind gift that any football fan will love. Quality is top notch”
- Anna on January 3, 2026
“My boyfriend is a huge Colts fan. These are perfect. It's been a great conversation piece.”
- Etsy Customer on April 17, 2016
With each coaster, you'll not only protect your surfaces but also honor the unforgettable moments that define your Indianapolis Colts fandom. Whether for yourself or as a gift for your father, friend, husband, or more - we know these coasters are sure to rock! (pun intended).
Order this unique coaster set today and let the memories live on.
2007 Super Bowl XLI
Hayden Pick Six
Colts vs Chicago
29 - 17
4 February, 2007
The Super Bowl started poorly with Devin Hester's kickoff TD for the Bears, but Manning rallied the Colts taking the lead in the 2nd and extending it in the 3rd. It was Kelvin Hayden's 56 yd interception and TD in the 4th that sealed the game and got Indianapolis and Manning their first Super Bowl.
2003 Regular Season, Week 5
4th Quarter Comeback
Colts vs Tampa Bay
38 - 35
6 October, 2003
It's one of the greatest comebacks ever. The Colts were down 3 TDs with 4 minutes left when Brad Pyatt's 90 yd return reignited the team. A rushing TD and a recovered onside kick set Peyton Manning up for a 28 yd TD pass to Marvin Harrison. Ricky Williams tied it and the Colts won by a FG in OT.
2007 AFC Championship
Ending the dynasty
Colts vs New England
38 - 34
21 January, 2007
By the 4th quarter the Colts had overcome a 21-3 deficit and set the stage for an epic QB duel. The Colts won it with a last minute drive that ended when Joseph Addai rushed into the endzone. Manning got his biggest win in 9 years, finally taking the Colts to a Super Bowl.
2013 Regular Season, Week 7
Manning vs. Luck
Colts vs Denver
39 - 33
20 October, 2013
Peyton Manning was returning to Indy with his new team and would face the new QB that the Colts were hoping would fill Manning's shoes. The Broncos pulled out to an early lead, but the Colts took the lead in the 2nd quarter on a 20 yd TD pass from Luck to Stanley Havili, never trailing after that.
Common questions
Are these a good gift for a Colts fan?▾
Yes. This coaster set is made for a Colts fan who really knows and loves the team. They’ll recognize moments like Hayden Pick Six and 4th Quarter Comeback, and each coaster gives them another piece of Colts history to talk about. It’s more than a logo on a coaster — it’s a way to relive the plays and memories that made them a fan. It’s especially suited to a dad, husband, friend, or hard-to-shop-for Colts fan who already owns the usual team gear.
Is this a good Christmas gift for a Colts fan?▾
Yes. These coasters make a unique Christmas gift for Colts fans, especially someone who already has plenty of jerseys, hats, and traditional team gear. Each coaster brings back a memorable moment from Colts history, making the set both useful and personal to someone who really follows the team. Our coaster sets are especially popular as Christmas gifts, with more than 16,000 five-star reviews across Shopify and Etsy.
One customer wrote: “The quality is insane, perfectly matched description. Bought for my dad for Christmas and as a man that is incredibly hard to buy for he loved them and are a great convo starter with his friends, Great gift would buy from this seller again.” — Etsy Customer, January 11, 2023
What makes these different from traditional sports merchandise?▾
These coasters focus on memorable plays rather than a team logo. Each one features an original Playbook diagram of a real Colts play, drawn to show how the moment unfolded. Playbook Products is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Colts or the NFL.
How long do Colts coaster orders take to ship?▾
Most Colts coaster orders are processed within 1–2 business days, then typically arrive 2–4 business days after they ship (U.S.). During busy holiday periods, processing can take longer. A delivery date shown on this page is an estimate.
What if a coaster arrives cracked or damaged?▾
Send us a photo of the damaged coaster within 14 days of delivery and we'll send a replacement. Please hold onto the damaged coaster until we let you know otherwise.
Are these coaster designs AI-generated?▾
No. I've spent hundreds of hours reviewing footage of these plays and drawing them up as they happened. The finished drawings are laser-etched onto the coasters using our own machines. The artwork is not generated by AI. I appreciate you supporting a small business.
What do customers say about Playbook coaster sets?▾
Playbook Products has more than 16,000 five-star reviews across our storefronts. Customers have described the coaster sets as unique gifts for sports fans who can be difficult to shop for. Recent customers have said:
“What an awesome gift. Especially if it’s for a person who has everything!! … It is now my new favorite gift!!” — Gerilyn, Sept. 30, 2026
“I gave this as a gift to a friend and he said it’s one of the best gifts he’s ever received! Enough said!” — La, Sept. 5, 2026
NOTICE: No sports player, team, league, or playoff is affiliated with Playbook Products or is the source of, is responsible for, or has endorsed, sponsored, or authorized these products or this website.
